Workplace-focused mandate
3,783 votes
NEC : Vote against
Members : 83.7% in favour
Our editorial position
Our position is straightforward: CAPE’s national resources should focus on workplace issues. Below are the documents behind our argument, alongside the context needed to read them fairly.
3,783 votes
NEC : Vote against
Members : 83.7% in favour
3,542 votes
NEC : Vote against
Members : 80.9% in favour
3,805 votes
NEC : Vote in favour
Members : 81.4% against
3,889 votes
NEC : Backed the proposal
Members : 76.3% against
3,394 votes
NEC : Vote in favour
Members : 74.2% against
2,891 votes
NEC : Vote in favour
Members : 68.0% against
Percentages use votes for and against and exclude abstentions. These are results among participating voters, not percentages of all CAPE members.
2025 membership vote results (Source in English)In 2025, the NEC recommended a campaign concerning Israel-related public-service pension investments, estimated at $250,000. It also backed lobbying the federal government to recognize Israel’s actions in Gaza as genocide.
That is the allocation of time, money and energy we oppose. Our union should concentrate on bargaining, job security, grievances and working conditions.
The $250,000 was an implementation estimate, not proof of money spent. Proponents linked divestment to pension ethics and solidarity. The separate dues proposal sought a percentage-based model; we do not claim that proposal funded only external campaigns.
2025 AGM documents and voting package (Source in English)The NEC advised members to reject the workplace-focused mandate. It passed with 3,783 votes in favour and 738 against: 83.7% support, excluding 682 abstentions.
That is a clear instruction to put members’ working lives first. CAPE’s time, money and energy should serve bargaining, job security and representation. Members United promises continuity with M4C. We want leadership that follows the workplace-focused mandate.
The NEC defended a broader mandate as helpful to equity, coalitions and bargaining. Our criticism concerns the allocation of union resources. Protection against workplace discrimination remains an essential union responsibility.
The NEC recommended against stronger advance cost disclosure for resolutions costing at least $500 or likely to raise dues. It argued that existing financial review was sufficient and the proposed threshold too low.
We disagree. A proposal should clearly show what it will cost, what members may have to pay and how it advances their interests at work. Members are entitled to that level of financial accountability.
This criticism concerns that specific recommendation. In 2024, members approved fuller NEC minutes and meeting recordings: 1,499 in favour, 116 opposed and 290 abstentions. We do not claim members rejected every reform.
2024 membership vote results (Source in English)NEC spending: misplaced priorities
We consider it irresponsible to commit union resources to non-workplace political campaigns when members need bargaining support, job security and representation. The NEC must answer for those choices. Every dollar and hour devoted to these campaigns is a resource that could serve members at work. Members should be able to trust their elected leaders to be responsible stewards of the Association’s budget, follow its rules and protect the dues entrusted to them.
The Ottawa Citizen reports that in 2024, the NEC had approved funding for CAPE 4 Palestine. According to the petition cited in the article, $5,000 came from the executive contingency budget. More than 60 members signed a petition seeking a review of CAPE’s donation spending. About 200 people attended the special meeting.
The report also lists $3,000 donated to striking PSAC workers, $500 to the student Palestine advocacy group INSAF and $1,000 to the Grassy Narrows River Run. Petitioners sought greater transparency, consultation before decisions and rules to prevent conflicts of interest.
Following this controversy, members adopted two resolutions in the 2024 AGM membership vote. Stronger donation rules passed by 1,259 votes to 496, requiring eligible recipients at arm’s length from leadership, advance publication of requests and non-renewable donations. A separate resolution passed by 965 votes to 710. It directed that the $5,000 contribution be charged to the President’s Discretionary Fund instead of the executive contingency budget, and that future contributions to CAPE for Palestine or any affiliated or successor group cease.
Counts above exclude abstentions: 150 on the donation policy and 230 on the funding resolution.
2024 membership vote results (Source in English)The petitioners argued that this funding was a donation exceeding the approved budget. CAPE disputed that classification and described it as support for a member initiative. The report documents a disagreement over rules and priorities; it does not establish a budget violation.
“My comments on Reddit were posted to a personal account and reflect my personal beliefs. I was not speaking as the President of the Canadian Association of Professional Employees.”
“I’ll say Jim Crow Jewish supremacists from now on, which more accurately describes you.”
“Oh and people don’t find your racial supremacy cute or inspiring, you Jim Crow hacks.”
Quoted in the June 2, 2025 report and attributed to Prier. The first addressed a user described as pro-Israel; the second addressed another user. The article does not establish that these recipients were Jewish CAPE members.
Union leader faces complaint over anti-Israel posts (Source in English)The National Post reports that Prier acknowledged owning the anonymous account. It quotes the posts below and reports that, according to the complaint, most comments appeared in public Reddit exchanges with other union members in late 2024. The complaint alleged harassment of Jewish CAPE members and use of a “sockpuppet” account to appear to be an independent supporter. The article also describes Prier commenting on an article in which he himself was quoted.
Nathan Prier wrote these words while serving as CAPE’s president. Jewish members are entitled to respectful representation, including when they disagree with him. Calling the account personal does not excuse this language. A union president should be able to defend his views without speaking to people this way or hiding his role. We oppose his re-election.
These quotations and the account acknowledgement are reported by the National Post. The harassment complaint is an allegation, not a verified disciplinary finding.
In a public Reddit reply, the ACEP-CAPE account acknowledges that CLC support was not clearly communicated. It says the CLC provides neither direct strike pay nor loans to affiliates. It describes logistical and communications help, and the possibility of requesting donations from other affiliates.
Members facing lost wages need specific answers: how much money is available, what strike pay is planned, and for how long? This correction warrants scrutiny of the information members received. It does not prove deliberate deception.